An exercise to try on improving your essay.
- Pick a few sentences from your essay with sensory details.
- Rewrite three more sentences with varying comparisons (avoiding cliches)
- Show three sentences to peers and pick the best sentence.
Here are some examples from an old essay.
- The air feels warm and humid.
- The air is like a sauna starting to warm the room.
- The air always had a touch of summer in it.
- Cold would be absent from here like water in a desert.
- Trade winds lazily drift through the area keeping it cool.
- Trade winds like cool silk drift across the expanse that is Rocky Hill.
- The trade winds fight against the heat while we work.
- Trade winds act like natural AC in a classroom.
- A small terraced pond with lily pads would be the last thing you see, with its lily pads on one terrace and taro plants on the other.
- The last thing you would see is a small terraced pond with platform-like lily pads with a patch of taro plants that have leaves like elephant ears.
- In a terraced lily pond, lily pads float on the surface like inner tubes in a pool next to a patch of taro plants.
- A taro plants bend gracefully over with leaves like hearts in a terraced lily pond along with lily pads.
Here is the critique received.
- The air feels warm and humid.
- The air is like a sauna starting to warm the room. [<I have heard this expression before, so it is a cliché.]
- The air always had a touch of summer in it. [<I really like this sentence. It is elegant and original.]
- Cold would be absent from here like water in a desert.
- Trade winds lazily drift through the area keeping it cool.
- Trade winds like cool silk drift across the expanse that is Rocky Hill. [I would delete the underlined part, but otherwise it is fantastic. That simile is unique, and it gives a good, tangible image of the winds. Good!]
- The trade winds fight against the heat while we work.
- Trade winds act like natural AC in a classroom.
- A small terraced pond with lily pads would be the last thing you see, with its lily pads on one terrace and taro plants on the other.
- The last thing you would see is a small terraced pond with platform-like lily pads with a patch of taro plants that have leaves like elephant ears.
- In a terraced lily pond, lily pads float on the surface like inner tubes in a pool next to a patch of taro plants. [<I like the active verb “float,” and the simile instantly gave me an image. Good job!]
- A taro plants bend gracefully over with leaves like hearts in a terraced lily pond along with lily pads. [I like the personification and active verb “bend.” (Noun-verb agreement needs to be worked out.)]
a. Cliche – The warm sun shines on the lake.
ReplyDeleteb. Simile – The sun shines on the water like fireflies shimmering in the night.
c. Metaphor – The lake is a sheet of glass, reflecting the light from the sun.
Cliché: The sun on the water like a face on a mirror
ReplyDeleteOriginal: The waves rippled on the water like little hills
Original: The house was peaceful like a restaurant on a Monday afternoon
Tom Sullivan
Mia Masuda
Winston Chang
ORIGINAL
ReplyDeleteas the porch waits for the presence of humans
the lake fist pumps to the beat of the mountains
with the clouds jerking in the sky
the trees puts its branches up high
a) CLICHÉ: The water was as clear as glass, and the sun reflected off the water like a mirror.
ReplyDeleteb) SIMILE: The silhouette of the mountains looms over the vast stretch of sea like a vigilant guardian.
c) METAPHOR: The sun was King, awakening his people for the day.
Slowly, the light of dawn dips on the resting waters. Mountains are the boundaries between sky and land.
ReplyDeleteThe sun awakens from night and stretches its shadows across the still-sleeping sea. The mountain is the rim to the ocean, allowing the water to dance without spilling. Just like the saying, ”Never miss it till it runs dry.”
(Shota's group)
ReplyDeleteCliche:The view of the beautiful lake and the shading mountains provide breathtaking scenery when you walk out on your porch.
Metaphor: The vast lake like a sheet of rippling ice act as the gateway to an alien world.
Original: The house was quiet and peaceful like a restaurant on a Monday afternoon.
ReplyDeleteThe sun was a luminous monarch, scrutinizing each ripple of sea with his gleaming rays.
ReplyDelete